Separate Statehood for Telangana: Where will the division of India stop? - Instablogs
Separate Statehood for Telangana: Where will the division of India stop?
Sameer Kumar , Hyderabad: Mar 20 2008
Made Popular Mar 20 2008
India :

Separate Statehood for Telangana: Where will the division of India stop?
If you look around the country right now, you are almost tempted to put a flag up on your own home and declare yourself a separate state with the complete majority of your house. The way in which we are setting a disastrous precedent time in and time out is almost lunatic. Just for a victory in the next coming elections, people with white coats and black cash are splitting the nation up in to pieces and causing damage which might have some grave repercussions. Short-sighted policies and lock of any kind of moral fabric is making sure that the few bad men at the top play jigsaw with a nation that is so dear to us.

Reading Indian history as a little kid, I have always been told that the most essential reason for an Island halfway across the planet to rule us for nearly 250 years was the simple fact that we had no unity. We allowed our mighty empire to dismantle itself in the name of ‘Local Pride’. Years after independence we are doing this again by giving states to anyone who so as puts in half a request. This breaking spree has gone on for too long and has gone a bit too far. Anyone who has a decent vote bank and has the voice to put in half a plea is almost guaranteed to get a separate state. This of course is provided the government in the center sees that its own party wins an election and forms a government in the newly formed state.

The problem of Telangana is nothing new. It has been a part of Andhra Pradesh since the day of the states formation. I come from Hyderabad and I do not actually feel either as someone from Andhra region of AP or its Telangana region. I just feel like a ‘Hyedarabadi’ but I’m surrounded by people who have an overwhelming sense of regionalism. It is one thing to be proud of your heritage, it is altogether another to try and take advantage of it. It is funny how in this time and age people of Telangana actually believe that a new state would improve their lives miraculously. This whole heightened hype about bringing back jobs to the locals is almost an absolute joke and in spirit goes against the constitution.

Historically speaking Telangana wanted to separate itself from Andhra since 1956 and even before that. But people then were coaxed and even forced in to submission so as to include its 9 districts in AP. The discontent has only grown with time. While it is hard to ignore popular sentiment, it is essential to note that popular sentiment is not always the right opinion. The areas backwardness which is the reason for bitterness among the localities stems from the fact that most of the terrain is dry and barren. The Andhra region is blessed with resources by nature and is lush green with both Krishna and Godavari rivers. Now people of Telangana are being cheated in to believing that a separate state is the answer to al their woes.

The problem with this is that the Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS), which says that it is fighting for Telangana, is that it has nothing constructively planned for the state apart from the fact that they want to rule a state. While they shout like wolfs in the African plains for a separate state, they never mention a constructive plan to develop it for next 5 years or even two. Once again ‘Vote-Fetching policies’ are replacing ‘Welfare Policies’ and people are being conned by men who are showing a Utopia in their palm. Andhra Pradesh was the first state to be formed on linguistic basis in this country. It is a tag we much rather not have. Hopefully Telangana won’t be the first state to be formed on basis of dialect! Maharashtra does not exclusively belong to Marathis and Bengal is not only a state for the Bengalis. Why can’t we understand that a state borders are for administrative convenience and not for personal convenience? Can we ever learn to share rather than stare eye to eye?

Image

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Desh
Shimla, India
Local interests are fast superseding national sovereignty. The present Telangana issue is an outburst of regionalism in the name of pacifying popular sentiments and propagating the vote bank politics. It’s sure that without any concrete planning as per the constitution of a new state, such demands should not be adhered to.
1 Stars
Kalpana Tripathi
Mumbai, Allahabad, India
I dont understand why every one wants their own territory, whats the need of separation. Well, might they dont know united we stand divided we fall! Its not just telangana asking for a separate state. All over the country you will notice such things, remember making of jharkhanda and all. If this separation process continues than sooner or later there would be demand for having a separate nation, India would be just remain a name only.
1 Stars
Nitesh
Chennai, India
The creation of smaller states, as the single solution to all problems, is not wise decision at all. The governments should work to implement the welfare policies to each of the backward regions in the state. They should make it sure that the development is properly distributed to all the regions.
1 Stars
Yash
Gwalior, India
The Telengana movement is all political drama and the Telangana Rashtra Samiti is not less than a joke in Andhra Pradesh politics. After spending three and half years in UPA they found their association as wrong and blamed UPA for not considering their demand. Till now, no visible progress has been made so far. All the leaders in Andhra are just talking about it in media. After all, who would decide who would get Hyderabad?
1 Stars
Milind
Thiruvananthapuram, India
No, I don't agree. India is a democratic country and every Indians have the rights of freedom of speech and expression. It is the duty of the state to work for the welfare of the state. In a democratic country like India, a section of the people have the right to demand a separate state, if they are not happy with the governance of the current state.
1 Stars
Yash
Gwalior, India
What I think is no one can make an argument whether a separate state or smaller state would receive better options for development. It actually depends on the vision of political leadership and if the leadership has the vision they can even develop bigger states too.
1 Stars
Avadhut
Calicut, India
The uneven development of the country is result of double-standard policies of previous central governments. When a selected number of states get central funds and industrial and irrigation developments, the other states would feel as cheated. MPs and MLAs should take care of the people of their constituencies to make sure that their regions received due importance and their own shares in the central funds.
1 Stars
Ayushi
Calicut, India
The people sitting in New Delhi will have to start working hard for balanced development of the states, otherwise the regional parties would try to take advantages of the backwardness of their states in elections by demanding smaller states for the people of backward regions. If it doesn't happen in due time, we will see many more demands for separate states in coming days.
1 Stars
Arefa
Kottayam, India
The productivity of any region cannot improve just in day when it becomes a separate state but the smaller state brings up additional expenses with no great resource of earnings. They will become dependent on central funds only.
1 Stars
Ekta
Jaipur, India
Demands and protests for smaller states are all political drama. Political leaders take initiative for separate state agitations just to win seats and to remain in power. What is happening now that the common people are being associated with such movements. They start thinking smaller states/separate states are the key of better development that is wrong perception.
1 Stars
Avadhut
Calicut, India
Creating smaller states sounds like breaking down a joint family and it is always a painful process for the people living in the region. Smaller states cannot magic when the question comes to the normal life of the common people of the region.
1 Stars
Andy
Navi Mumbai, India
Its all power game. Lalu Prasad once had said that the separate Jharkhand could be made only on his dead body but later he accepted because for him Jharkhand was not his political belt and creating Jharkhand will always give him the chance to rule the separate Bihar. Unfortunately Lalu lost power in Bihar and after eight years of creation, Jharkhand is as it was in 1999. Mayawati is doing the same thing and TRS is trying to do the same.
1 Stars
Shameem
Aligarh, India
Dreams of development can't be fulfilled by creating smaller states and just in days. States can be developed by proper planning, adequate funds and willingness to implement the plan. The will-power of leadership of the state is important, not the demand of separate states.
1 Stars
Sweta
Gwalior, India
Telangana is must for the people living in the region. There are three regions in Andhra Pradesh - coastal Andhra, Rayalaseema and Telangana. Everyone in the state says that Telangana, region of 10 districts, is the most neglected of the three. Scarcity of water is the biggest problem in the region despite the presence of rivers like Krishna and Godavari.
1 Stars
Chandni
Allahabad, India
Today, Telangana can be seen as the best example of discrimination in India, particularly in South India. The region has given two chief ministers to Andhra and one prime minister to the country but still the region is backward than other two regions in Andhra Pradesh. The literacy rates in coastal Andhra and Rayalaseema are 46% and 45% but it is just 37% in Telangana. There is only one university out of eleven and 20 polytechnics out of 91 in the state. This is why Telangana people are asking for separate state.
1 Stars
Milind
Thiruvananthapuram, India
I would still prefer smaller states because the smaller states have more revenue and less expenditure on leaders and bureaucracy. Political stability is one important thing we can have in smaller states.
1 Stars
Sameer Kumar
Hyderabad, India
@ Milind
”In a democratic country like India, a section of the people have the right to demand a separate state, if they are not happy with the governance of the current state.”

If that is how you see the functioning of Democracy then most nations in the world are in serious trouble. If you are not happy with the administration then change it with the power of your vote and by spreading awareness. If smaller states can improve bad administration over night then we would have been a nation of 75 states by now.
1 Stars
Jaiyant Cavale
Bangalore, India
We do not have a strong Central Government and that is the root cause for all over internal problems. I wish Delhi would tame all these rogue organizations into silence so that we preserve our national integrity. It is high time the government did something!
1 Stars
Sameer Kumar
Hyderabad, India
I do not know if they are all exactly ’rogue organizations’, but they sure as hell cause more trouble than needed and the demands are just irrational and only aimed at fulfilling their own personal political ambitions. It is sad that the vast majority are falling for the trap.
Add your Comment